The Two Sides of Guilt: Healthy vs. Toxic

Reclaim Psychotherapy
May 15
4 min read

We’ve all felt it—that gnawing pit in our stomach when we think we’ve done something wrong. Guilt is a universal human emotion, but not all guilt is created equal. Some guilt helps us grow and repair; other guilt traps us in a cycle of self-blame and shame. Let’s break down the difference between helpful, healthy guilt and unhelpful, toxic guilt.

Healthy Guilt: Guilt as a Sign of Values Transgression

What It Is: Healthy guilt is like your moral compass nudging you back on course. It’s the psychological discomfort we feel when we’ve done something that genuinely goes against our values or ethical standards.

Example: Jordan promised to help a friend move but canceled last minute because they wanted to play video games. Now, Jordan feels guilty for letting their friend down.

Why It Happens: Healthy guilt arises when our actions break reasonable standards of right and wrong. It’s a reaction to having done something we believe is against our values or moral standards.

What It’s Telling You: Healthy guilt says, “I messed up, and I need to make amends.” It’s a signal that something needs repairing. Importantly, it doesn’t say, “I am a bad person”—it says, “What I did was not good.”

The Upside: When we listen to healthy guilt, it can lead to growth and healing. It pushes us to seek forgiveness, correct our mistakes, and realign with our values. It’s a call to action that’s ultimately constructive.

When It Develops: Guilt, in general, begins to emerge around ages 3 to 6 as we start understanding moral rules and consequences. Healthy guilt reflects a mature emotional response that focuses on actions rather than self-worth.

How It Resolves: Healthy guilt fades as we take steps to repair the damage. Whether it’s apologizing, making amends, or learning from the experience, the discomfort dissipates when we’ve done what we can to make things right and hold ourselves accountable for our wrongdoing.

Toxic Guilt: Guilt as a Product of Excessive Responsibility and Impossible Standards

What It Is: Toxic guilt, on the other hand, is a harsh inner critic that’s impossible to satisfy. It stems from unrealistic or overly high standards, leaving us feeling bad about things that are not our responsibility or within our control.

Example: Taylor respectfully told their date that they were no longer interested in seeing them because they didn't feel it was a romantic match. Taylor felt guilty that their date felt sad and rejected.

Why It Happens: Toxic guilt often arises from irrational beliefs, like “I must never make a mistake,” or “I am responsible for everyone’s happiness,” or "I should never upset others." These beliefs often have roots in childhood, especially in environments with high expectations, family enmeshment, or when children are made to feel responsible for their parents' emotions.

What It’s Telling You: Toxic guilt whispers, “You should be able to get everything right, always be able to prevent anything bad from happening, and if someone is upset, it's your fault" It doesn't allow limits to your level of responsibility for events or for other people - it tells you you are totally responsible. Toxic guilt is also one of the main things that gets in our way of having reasonable and healthy boundaries with others, telling you: "You can't set that boundary! They will be upset! Think about their feelings, not yours."

The Downside: Instead of encouraging growth, toxic guilt traps you in a cycle of imposing expectations of responsibility no human can possibly (or should) meet, followed by self-blame. Unlike healthy guilt, which focuses on actions, toxic guilt attacks your sense of self.

When It Develops: Like healthy guilt, toxic guilt can emerge as early as ages 3 to 6. However, it’s often shaped by perfectionism or learned behaviors from a childhood spent trying to please demanding or unreasonable adults.

How It Resolves: The key to overcoming toxic guilt lies in challenging the irrational beliefs behind it. This might mean learning to embrace imperfection, letting go of excessive responsibility for others, and practicing self-compassion. It may also simply require that you practice noticing and tolerating the temporary feeling of toxic guilt without allowing it to control your actions.

Final Thoughts

By recognizing the type of guilt you’re experiencing, you can better respond to it. Healthy guilt invites you to repair and grow, while toxic guilt asks for gentleness and a reevaluation of your beliefs. Both feelings can be managed with intention and self-awareness.

So next time guilt comes knocking, take a moment to reflect. Is it a helpful nudge or an unfair weight? The answer can make all the difference.

Looking for Support? We can help!

We provide online counselling and psychotherapy services across Ontario. While we work with clients of all backgrounds and genders, our practice specializes in empowering adults in their late teens, 20s, and 30s to reclaim confidence, happiness, and fulfillment, despite the challenges of low self-esteem, anxiety, and relationship struggles.

If you are in need of support for cultivating a greater sense of self-worth or self-confidence, we’d love to hear from you! Click the button below to book.

Book Now!